About a month ago a Brazilian player walked off the field in La Liga after he was racially abused throughout the match. This incident was reported and fines were slapped on the alleged culprits of this act, but many feel that while FIFA has technically made efforts to cease racist remarks, it is “nonsense to fight racism with fines”. And while FIFA is under the spotlight with the impending 2014 World Cup in Rio De Janeiro, there is now another incident of not allowing a black couple to host the final World Cup event and decided to elect a white couple for the job. While this is still only an alleged accusation, this is simply a continued view that FIFA does not want to have and is furthering the image that they are racially intolerant.
Category Archives: Uncategorized
Carter PCQs:Fascist Football Foundation
Fascist Football Foundation
Introduction:
-Italy felt the need to restructure football in order to gain the support of the masses. This in turn becomes another form of nationalism.
-The new league of calico formed in the early 20th century was the cause of much disapproval from the smaller clubs, which in turn caused a divide in big and small clubs and strayed away from the initial belief of “a healthy and chivalrous game that tempers the energies of the race”. Continue reading
The reforms that were made to the soccer program did not benefit the small clubs. This caused the smaller clubs to reject ideas that would benefit the larger clubs when things were voted upon. This made the larger clubs form other confederations. The issues that the small clubs faced were that they could not acquire the best players because the larger clubs got them all. This also forced the small clubs to drop into leagues where they could compete and make money. Large clubs were able to build up a following by paying fans to go to away games. Acquiring the best athletes was a vital part to the clubs success but we also see that fan support was a major factor in the outcome of games. While the game was developing so was the officiating aspect. We see from the article that the referees were conscientious about where they were when making calls and how the call would be received by the fans and later the committee.
The protracted season also only highlighted the stark division between the wealthy and poor clubs. A rich minority capable of winning the title had emerged but the demands placed upon them had also become more exacting as supporters demanded stronger squads, which required more money to attract the best players. Many games had also become unattractive mismatches between the rich and poor, the real business of the season commencing only once the play-off positions had been decided. Unable to break into the league’s elite due to their financial limitations, the poorer teams were left with little to fight for other than survival (Martin 56). Continue reading
TIFO 2: Catalonia and Basque Country reignite call for independent national football identities
Here is the article I’ve found.
I think it’s really cool to look at the perspectives at play in this article. The people of Cataluña and the Basque country want these teams to represent and be the forefront for their nationalist movements, but at least the Catalan players continue the tradition of saying whatever the people want to hear. Xavi’s quote is an example of this, how he says the likes to play for Cataluña but ultimately would play for Spain, not Cataluña. This quote is classic, “The players do so carefully stressing their allegiance to Catalonia, while never publicly championing it ahead of their loyalty to a Spain they have all represented with distinction.” Why would these Catalan players try to change a system that they are extremely successful at? The Catalans have always been known as “wheeler-dealers” and negotiators, so it’s really cool to watch this play out.
PCQ 3
Who Really Invented Modern Football?
This article focuses on the development of soccer as we know it today. A concise summary of this seems to be that Sheffield was the hub of a amateur, elite soccer scene, while Lancashire focused on the competition of sport. Sheffield changed the rules and helped form soccer into what the game is today, like with the offside rule mentioned on page 1428. It seems that Lancashire, with its sporting traditions of horse racing and pedestrianism, wanted good players and good competition. They used what the reading calls “shamateur game” and “they [the players] were paid quite openly out of the gate money, the net sum remaining after those disbursements being entered in the books kept for inspection as gross amounts’.” (pg 1437) Ultimately the game continued to grow and become what it is today, but it is really interesting to see such different perspectives of a game work together to form a lasting sport.
A History of Football in Paris:
Capital and port areas were main places for soccer in the beginning, but this changed. Compulsory military service helped spread the game across the country and the article seems to say that this happened across class lines. Before soccer was a city or port area thing, but during the 1920’s this spread to the provinces around France, indicating that the game was spreading thanks to the compulsory military service, and these new teams were winning. “In redefining spheres of influence, this new institutional configuration once again brought into play the French regions’ mistrust of Parisian power in a country already defined by a long tradition of centralisation going back to the division of the country into departments following the French Revolution” (pg. 1133) This is really interesting, the once dominant power was stopped and made to be equal, which is way different from the “creation” story of Brazil.
The story of football in France also has “identity portals” like with the Italians in Brazil. It is really interesting to see that immigrants used soccer to find to find their own “place” within the culture and to be accepted.
When were the rules hammered out again? How did they choose rules across country lines, when the rules changed as much as they did?
Carter PCQs 1/8/14
Who Really Invented Modern Football
Introduction:
-Football became a means of maintaining rivalries and boosting nationalism during the 19th century.
The Rules of football and Sheffield’s contributions: Continue reading
Who Really Invented Modern Football
Who Really Invented Modern Football
Nominal record linkage indicates that this development was essentially driven by schoolteachers, clerks, bookkeepers and accountants using their social and cultural capital rather than the transference of public school culture through returning public schoolboys.
Reaction: This is interesting how a sport like soccer that was not played by all used by schools. What was the purpose if not a lot of people played it?
The counties of Lancashire and Yorkshire were, however, to maintain their fierce rivalry and, by the nineteenth century, this had translated onto the sporting field. Part of this rivalry will be examined in this article as we identify and discuss the contribution of the two counties in the north of England and their distinctive roles in the creation of modern professional association football.(1427)
Reaction: In class we talked about how soccer was a way of showing superiority well this stanza shows that you can be united but you will always have differences. Also we see that the creation of soccer was drawn from other sports like rugby and the rules and regulations were implemented as the years moved along. We start to see a discrepancy in who followed which rules the FA or the Sheffield’s. Along with not knowing what rules to follow both contradicted one another. To answer the question of who invented soccer I feel that it came together as the years went on. We see that rules were created and then changed by other individuals to make the game different than Rugby. Schools were also important in the spread of the game also.
Jordan Adams TIFO 2
http://espnfc.com/news/story/_/id/1658394/zlatan-ibrahimovic-rule-future-mls?cc=5901
I thought I would point this article out that I found on ESPN just to continue the theme of my last TIFO. One of the most important parts of growing the brand of the MLS is trying to maintain its better players and attract new ones. Bringing in Zlatan would be a great step towards making the MLS a more attractive place for European players to play.
Jordan Adams PCQ 3
On Bosworth Field or the Playing Fields of Eton and Rugby? Who Really Invented Modern Football PCQ
The introduction to this article attempts to explain that before football became a competitive professional sport an established and flourishing sporting culture already existed. Foot races, horse racing, boxing, and cricket were the main sports that were popular before the development of professional football. Throughout the 1870’s however football quickly joined the ranks of other popular and commercialized sports which led to it reaching a level of professionalism. This process began due to the rivalry that existed between the countries of Lancashire and Yorkshire which shifted their competition from war and violence to the sporting field.
The Rules of Football and Sheffield’s Contribution
“Without that book of football laws, the games would never have been invented and the World would have been a much poorer place’, in fact, the code was very poor and far from disseminating the ‘kicking’ variety of football, it rapidly alienated many of those who were sympathetic to the game.” (1428) Continue reading
Eamon Bousa PCQ 3
On Bosworth Field or the Playing Fields of Eton and Rugby? Who Really Invented Modern Football?
In the article about the origins of modern football the authors discuss what region of England is truly responsible for the game of modern football we know today. The article discusses early football and how the game looked different then how we think of the game today and how the rules evolved. The Sheffield region seemed to get the game into its more modern form in terms of rules. In the region the sport enjoyed popularity among the elite although it was limited to amateurism due to the preferences of the elite who for religious or other reasons declined to allow the game in that region to be played professionally. Since these men controlled the sport in the region the game was played at the amateur level.
In Lancashire the situation was different. While the region adopted the basic rules of the game from Sheffield the region embraced professional players much more so that the Sheffield region. Much of that difference in preference had to do with who was playing football in Lancashire compared to Sheffield at the time. The Lancaster region players and club organizers were from the emerging lower middle class.
