Author Archives: Cole

Cole PCQ 1/16/2014 Problems with 21st Century Football

Racism, Sexism, and International Migration in 21st Century Football

The football academies in the United Kingdom are an excellent example of how commercialized and global all aspects of the game have become.  These youth football academies were originally formed to propagate talented football players from an early age.  By having Premier League clubs sponsor these schools, these clubs got were able to keep the talent for themselves and in the UK.  Recently, other countries have followed the UK’s example, but with one key difference; from the start, they actively sought out young players from around the world for their academies.  These academies are also responsible for teaching the youth players workforce skills to fall back on in case their football dreams fall short.

By actively looking for and recruiting youth players from around the world, European football academies are embodying some of the founding ideas of the European Union.  Even if the extranational youth players do not make it in the big leagues, they become a part of that country’s workforce and contribute to its global image.   Continue reading

Cole TIFO 1/16/2014 Addition to Yesterday’s TIFO

Continuation of Yesterday’s TIFO

I found this article today and lists some more great examples of how Bayern Munich is using the player transfer market to dominate not just the German league, but all of Europe.  By signing on any player from any other team in Europe, Bayern has effectively consolidated many of the best players in the game into their team.  While this is a key element of Bayern’s success, other teams are left picking of the pieces after losing some of their best players year after year.

Cole PCQ 1/15/2014 European Nationalism and Football since the 1970s

European Nationalism and Football since the 1970s

The rebirth that the Dutch football team went through for the 2006 World Cup is interesting because instead of looking to the outside to help fix the team, the Dutch federation selected in-house talent.  They decided that their team was going to become the best by being entirely Dutch instead of the now traditional model of having players and coaches from different countries form a national team.  The joint commitment the team expressed about their “way of playing is more important than the result is” is an interesting philosophy in sports, especially for a team who was trying to return to their global dominance in the World Cup.  The Netherlands wanted to be able to have a sense of nationalism and feeling of true Dutch unity.  By using only in-house players and coaching, they sought to bring back a Dutch identity and answer the “who are we?” question.

After their loss in the finals of the 1974 World Cup to Germany, the Dutch team did not return home as losers but were welcomed home as champions.  By defeating traditional powerhouse teams like Argentina and Brazil and making it to the finals with Germany showed the people of the Netherlands that their tiny country could compete on the world stage with the best of them.  The 1974 team became a symbol of what the Netherlands could really do.   Continue reading

Cole TIFO 1/15/2014 A Consolidation of Power

This article demonstrates how the German Football League, the Bundesliga, is experiencing a similar problem to the Italian league’s beginning of a small number of teams holding all the best players.  Right now, Bayern Munich is in that position of power and their rivals, Borussia Dortmund, who were right behind them last year have fallen to fourth place.  A lot of Dortmund’s woes this year stem from injuries, but because they do not have the depth of highly skilled players like Bayern Munich, they are having a hard time staying on top.

Cole PCQ 1/14/2014 US and Them

America’s Soccer Identity

In his article, Buffington describes what makes America unique in the area of soccer and defining the idea of a national culture.  One passage that seemed spot on to my thinking about now different nations have different playing styles.

“This involves representing national teams (and their individual members) as having distinctive habits of play, tactical affinities, or skill sets that influence how they perform on the field.”

He also brings up an interesting point about how highly industrialized nations were brought together under a unified sporting culture all around the 1870s and 1930s.  In America though, this was when baseball, basketball, and American football were gaining traction.  By having these three sports all hitting their high points during this time period, it left little room for the growth of soccer from its position as a youth sport your mom drove you to and from.  The idea of a “soccer mom” is an exclusively American idea and helps keep soccer as a youth sport.

Questions:

  • Would soccer be a big time sport here in the US if we did not have basketball or one of the other “American” sports emerging during the 1870s and 1930s?
  • What is an explanation of the growth in popularity soccer is experiencing now in the US?

Cole TIFO 1/14/2014

A Team Attitude

Franck Ribery’s third place finish in the competition for the 2014 Ballon d’Or is nothing to be taken lightly considering the first and second place finishers of Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi.  From the start of him finding out he was one of the three being considered for the trophy, he remained humble and expressed that he finds just being in the top three of the world is an honor enough.  Ribery also remarks that he “would rather win it all again with Bayern Munich and win the world title. That is what really matters. Of course, I would have liked to win the award, but what else could I have done than winning all trophies with Bayern?”  This team attitude is part of what makes Bayern Munich’s success so stable.

An Italian Football Renaissance Under Fascism? Cole Sylvester PCQ 1/9/2014

Italian Football Renaissance

Italian football in its infancy was riddled with arguments and fighting due to the smaller clubs holding a majority over the larger clubs in the FIGC.  This struggle is very similar to the way the smaller states did not want to have the larger states always holding the power of decisions in the creation of the United States Congress.  But the way the FIGC handled the situation led to a split in Italian club football, where the smaller teams were left to fend for themselves while the larger teams made all the money and got the best players.  To add to these issues was the inability of the referees to keep control of the game and enforce the rules.

Although widely considered to have been the best referee in Italy at the time, Mauro was far away from the incident in question, which intensified the Bologna fans’ conviction that the ball had crossed the line for a goal. Among those supporters was the leader of the Bolognese Fascist Federation and future mayor, Leandro Arpinati, who, apparently, led a pitch invasion with his squadristi that culminated in shouting, pushing, threats and some skirmishes. 13 Choosing personal safety over conscience, Mauro reversed his decision and awarded a goal. (Martin, 54) Continue reading

Is the Best Still to Come? TIFO 1/9/2014

Is the Best Still to Come?

In this article, the author makes many good points about how once a team has reached the pinnacle of club football, it is only a matter of time until they fall.  Bayern Munich’s success is akin to that of Barcelona’s in the early 2000’s when, even if they did not hold the Champions League trophy, they were the team to beat.  But right now, it seems that Bayern is holding onto this spot for the long run by signing “one of the best and most coveted strikers on the planet” and having Pep Guardiola (Barcelona’s old coach) to keep the winning momentum going.

Early Football History in England and France – by Cole Sylvester

Cole PCQ 1/8/2014

In Peter Swain and Adrian Harvey’s article on the origins of modern football, they explain how football’s origins center around a rudimentary rule system that is almost completely different from any of the rules we know now.

In this early form, football and rugby were very similar in their rules and styles of play.  It wasn’t until Sheffield FA’s football culture improved to the point where they were able to host their own cup competition.

This first football cup was sponsored by a local businessman who even contributed a trophy to the winner of the 12 team competition.

Because of this influence, Sheffield FA was able to prevent the disbandment of the FA.  These early games were not commercial pursuits, rather presided over by amateurs.  But as interest in these games increased, the clubs began charging admission to the games as they were now played in commercial gardens and enclosed public house fields.

French Contributions to the Game of Football:

“During the Third Republic conscripts were required to undergo military service, which was often carried out in regiments far from the Seine De´partement. As soon as Parisian players arrived in their regiment, they almost always got together a football team and, insofar as sport did not figure on the athletics programme of French military training, encouraged practice of it by, among other things, requesting that their home teams sent footballs.

Questions:

  • How did the competition between France and Britain in the 19th and 20th centuries contribute to the quality of the players and game of football we know today?
  • How did the changing social and economic dynamics of the players and supporters of the game of football influence the spread of the popularity of the game?

TIFO: “Neuer Named World’s Best Goalkeeper” – by Cole Sylvester

This article shows how German players are reaching the pinnacle of their careers just as the World Cup is coming around again. Neurer’s upsetting of Spanish icon Iker Casillas’s five year reign over the award demonstrates how Spain’s aging national team is losing its grip on the world stage.